The Western Cape High Court has declared invalid the suspension of Public Protector Advocate Busisiwe Mkhwebane.
President Cyril Ramaphosa suspended Advocate Mkhwebane, who is the subject of a Parliament Section 194 inquiry into her fitness to hold office, on 9 June 2022.
Advocate Mkhwebane then approached the court to challenge her suspension on the grounds, among others, that she said the President was conflicted as she was investigating complaints against him.
On Friday the high court in Cape Town ruled in favour of Mkhwebane saying her suspension was invalid.
Judge L G Nuku ruled: “The decision of the President to suspend the applicant is hereby declared invalid”.
The judge added: “The suspension of the applicant is hereby set aside effectively from the date of this order.”
Responding to the judgment, the Presidency said, “it has noted the ruling handed down by the Western Cape High Court this afternoon, 09 September 2022, stating that President Cyril Ramaphosas decision to suspend Adv. Busisiwe Mkhwebane is invalid.”
The Presidency said it will seek guidance from the Constitution on the next steps.
The first respondent in the matter, the National Assembly Speaker Nosiviwe Mapisa-Nqakula said she “notes the order of the Western Cape High Court delivered today dismissing Public Protector Adv Busisiwe Mkhwebanes application to, amongst others, declare the conduct of the Speaker and certain decisions of the Section 194 Committee to be unlawful”.
The Public Protector sought to challenge the conduct of the Speaker and decisions of the Section 194 Committee based on the following grounds:
The National Assembly (NA) failed to amend NA Rule 129AD(3) in line with the judgment of the Constitutional Court,
the unilateral determination by the Chairperson of the Section 194 Committee of the 30-day period within which the Public Protector was required to respond to the allegations as well as the failure and/or refusal to grant an extension,
the infringement of the sub judice rule (rule 89 of the NA Rules): and
sought an order by the High Court to develop the common law to include a rule automatically suspending the execution of an order which is the subject of a pending application for rescission.
“The Court held that it was not necessary for the NA to amend Rule 129AD(3) as the Constitutional Court had already done so,” the Speaker said.
“It further held that Adv Mkhwebane failed to present evidence before the Court demonstrating how she was prejudiced by the unilateral determination of the 30-day period as well as the alleged refusal to grant the extension that she requested of Chairperson of the Section 194 Committee.
“The extension that was allowed was fair according to the court.”
On the infringement of the sub judice rule, Mapisa-Nqakula said the Court held that the Public Protector placed no facts before it “to demonstrate that the inquiry by the Section 194 Committee would result in the members of the Committee having to reflect on the merits of her second application for rescission”.
The Speaker said importantly the court found that her writing a letter to the President informing him of the start of the process of the Section 194 Committee was factually correct and therefore not unlawful.
The Speaker said her actions were in line with the principle of cooperative government.
“The Section 194 Committee which is conducting an inquiry into the Public Protector, Advocate Mkhwebanes fitness to hold office is currently continuing with its meetings,” said Mapisa-Nqakula.
“‘At the completion of its inquiry, the Committee is expected to present a report which must contain findings and recommendations to be considered by the National Assembly.”
FULL JUDGEMENT:


