Johannesburg – Opposition parties including the Democratic Alliance (DA), and Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) are unhappy with the composition of the panel to assess if there are grounds to impeach President Cyril Ramaphosa over his Phala Phala game farm robbery and alleged cover-up.
In line with a request by the ATM to consider its motion to impeach the President, National Assembly Speaker Nosiviwe Mapisa-Nqakula on Wednesday appointed the panel comprising:
- Former chief justice, Sandile Ngcobo, who will chair the panel.
- Former Gauteng judge, Thokozile Masipa, who presided in the high-profile Oscar Pistorius trial; and
- Prof Richard Calland, associate professor of public law at the University of Cape Town.
Reacting to the appointment, the DA on Thursday said it was “deeply concerned about the composition of the Section 89 Inquiry that will be investigating President Cyril Ramaphosa’s complicity in the robbery at his Phala Phala farm.”
Although opposition parties were invited to nominate persons to be considered for the panel, none of the people they recommended made it.
The rules of the National Assembly, which were adopted to give effect to Section 89 of the Constitution are clear.
“The Speaker ought to select – following consultation with the parties represented in Parliament – three members who are “fit and proper, competent, experienced and respected South African citizens, which may include a Judge,” said the DA.
“More importantly, the panel should be independent and objective in order to do its work without fear or prejudice.
“While the DA has no concerns about the members of the judiciary who have been appointed, we are not convinced of Professor Richard Calland’s objectivity and independence.
“Professor Calland is no doubt a respected academic in the legal fraternity but is also a political commentator who routinely plays into the political fray; publicly offering his political views especially as it pertains to the President.
“The rules do make provision for the inclusion of an academic, however, the inclusion of Professor Calland will inevitably threaten the legitimacy and the integrity of the entire process.”
The EFF rejected the panel, saying the appointments were “irrational, bias, and are a complete disregard of the consultative process with political parties represented in Parliament”.
The EFF added: “The most appalling of the appointments, is that of Richard Calland, who is an Associate Professor at the University of Cape Town and an unrepentant advocate and admirer of Ramaphosa.
“‘He has on multiple occasions taken platform on broadcast, print, and social media to laud Cyril Ramaphosa for factional activity within the ANC, and even going to the extent of giving him advice on policy, and how to approach governance at the expense of his detractors and political opponents.
“Calland has criticised Members of Parliament for holding Ramaphosa accountable and publicly declared his support for Ramaphosa to get a second term at the ANC Presidency on social media.
“He does not have a strand of Independence in him and is a self-styled political analyst who will denigrate the process with his blind hatred for Ramaphosa’s political enemies.
“Mapisa-Nqakula has brought shame to Parliament and the Constitution of South Africa with appointments which are pre-determined and will absolve Ramaphosa of the breach of his oath of office.”
The EFF said it will consult with other political parties represented in Parliament “to reverse the appointment of a panel of Ramaphosa’s cheerleaders”.
However, the ATM, which requested the impeachment of Ramaphosa, said it “commends the Speaker for taking only two weeks to apply her mind and balance many variables with the result that the Independent Panel has now been announced”.
The ATM said it was “alive to some of the complimentary public comments by Professor Richard Calland towards Mr. Ramaphosa”.
The ATM added: “However, in good faith, we will not delay the process challenging his appointment.
“The view we take as the ATM is that all the panelists will conduct themselves in an objective manner and ensure that the objects of the Constitution are upheld, defended, and respected.”
The ATM said it is “furthermore convinced that the work of the panel should be very easy because the standard against which they will be evaluating submitted evidence is cast in stone, and also that the evidence submitted is not only uncontested but incontestable”.
The ATM said it feels the evidence submitted is compelling and ticks all the boxes.
“There is just no way the panel can ignore the fact that even as we speak there is no case opened for the criminality that took place in Phalaphala farm despite Mr. Ramaphosa being in the know,” said the ATM.
“It will be impossible for the panel to look past the fact that Ramaphosa is on record instructing his head of security to investigate the burglary in his private farm and thus violating the Constitution because that unlawful instruction put him at a risk of a conflict between his official duty versus his private interests.
“The two concrete examples above are enough to kick start the actual Impeachment process.”
Ramaphosa, who has left for the US to meet President Joe Biden before attending the send-off in London of Queen Elizabeth II, denies any wrongdoing and has requested that the various law enforcement agencies investigating the allegations levelled against him be given space to conclude their work.
“The fact that various investigating agencies have been dragging their feet and giving Mr. Ramaphosa all manner of extensions shouldn’t really matter because one violation is one violation too much,” said the ATM.


