Parliament – The National Assembly – after taking legal advice on the sub judice rule – on Thursday said the Section 89 inquiry and whether or not to refer President Cyril Ramaphosa’s matter to an Impeachment Committee will go ahead.
Although Ramaphosa is taking on review the adverse report of the three-member panel that said he may have breached his oath of office regarding the 2020 robbery on his Phala Phala farm, Parliament said it will still go ahead with its processes.
RELATED: ConCourt: President Cyril Ramaphosa Files Papers Challenging Panel Report – The Bulrushes
“The pending application of the President does implicate the sub judice rule,” explained Advocate Z Adhikarie, Parliament’s Chief Legal Adviser.
“This creates a practical challenge of managing the debate. However, this cannot be an absolute bar to the National Assembly deciding whether to proceed with a section 89 enquiry and whether or not to refer the matter to an Impeachment Committee.
“However, it is permissible for the National Assembly to consider the fact that the President has launched a review application in determining its way forward.”
Advocate Adhikarie advised that in this regard, it would be rational for the National Assembly, in its discretion, and if so moved, to resolve that:
- a. a section 89 process should be proceeded with, or
- b. a section 89 process should not be proceeded with; or
- c. a decision on the section 89 process should be deferred until the pending application has been determined.
“Therefore, in light of the above we advise that the launch of the President’s review application unless an interdict were obtained, would not preclude the National Assembly from considering whether to proceed with a section 89 inquiry and refer the matter to an Impeachment Committee,” said Advocate Adhikarie.


