The Labour Court on Tuesday dismissed the contempt of court application lodged by Ruth Ntlokotse against the National Union of Metalworkers of South Africa (NUMSA).
The union’s former 2nd deputy president had filed an urgent application at the Labour Court requesting the NUMSA National Congress be declared “null and void” for allegedly going against an interdict.
Ntlokotse wanted the court to declare the 11th National Congress “null and void” because she said that the union failed to comply with the interdict order granted by Justice Moshoana.
Shee also asked the court to declare the NUMSA General Secretary Irvin Jim and President Andrew Chirwa in contempt of court for continuing with the congress.
Arguments were heard on Friday (19 August 2022).
However, on Tuesday Justice Van Niekerk ruled: “In so far as the applicant contends that the resolutions adopted by the special meeting of the central committee and the reconvening of the national congress on 27 July 2022 all constitute breaches of the court order and thus acts of contempt of court, it does not seem to me that a decision taken to postpone the commencement of the national congress until such time as the union fully complied with its constitution, constitutes a breach of the order. On the contrary, it is indicative of compliance with the order”.
The judge added: “I am not persuaded that the applicant has established a breach of the order beyond a reasonable doubt.”
The judge also ordered that each party must pay its own costs.
NUMSA said it “welcomed the ruling” as it has always maintained that it complied with the order of Justice Moshoana and this is why it proceeded with the congress.
“We are vindicated by this judgment. We will continue to defend the union and its decisions,” said Jim.


