Advocate Wim Trengove for the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) on Tuesday told the Pietermaritzburg High Court that Prosecutor Billy Downer “deserves a medal, not a condemnation”.
Trengove was countering arguments by Jacob Zuma’s lawyers that Prosecutor Downer must be removed from the corruption and money laundering case for misconduct and the former president acquitted.
Lawyers for Zuma have argued that Downer lacked the title to prosecute.
Advocate Dali Mpofu listed several instances that he said Downer acted in a manner that rendered him as lacking title.
From shedding tears when he heard the case against Zuma had been dropped, to leaking an affidavit with the former president’s confidential medical records to a female journalist, Downer’s conduct rendered him without title to prosecute, Advocate Mpofu said.
Zuma is seeking Downer’s recusal and acquittal from the case in which he faces decades-old allegations that he accepted bribes of R4.1-million, in 791 installments, from his then financial adviser Schabir Shaik.
Shaik allegedly organised the bribe that would see Zuma use his influence to help French arms manufacturer Thales secure contracts in the arms deal and avoid possible scrutiny.
Zuma faces corruption, racketeering and money laundering charges, Both he and Thales deny the allegations.
Among the many issues, Advocate Mpofu brought the attention of the court to a document penned by Downer that included Zuma’s confidential medical information that was recently leaked to the media.
Advocate Mpofu also raised the matter of Downer giving a public lecture on the Zuma matter. He said the lecture was a reason enough for Downer not to prosecute the matter.
Advocate Thabani Masuku also for Zuma said Downer was a “witness to crimes” committed within the NPA over 21 years regarding the former president’s prosecution and should not be allowed to prosecute the same matter.
Advocate Masuku referred to the clashes Downer has with subsequent NPA heads over the two decades the matter has been in and out of courts.
Downer’s joining a Democratic Alliance previous court matter against Zuma, was also a problem, said Advocate Masuku.
However, NPA prosecutor Advocate Wim Trengove said the attacks on Downer “were entirely unjustified”.
He said the one side selection of the facts by Zuma’s lawyers with an added dose of “hyperbole and insult for utterly innocent conduct” was not a reason to remove Downer from prosecuting the matter.
“Mr. Downer is owed an apology,” said Advocate Trengove.
“The man should be given a medal… he was the one who stood up to his bosses.”
Trengove, who said Zuma’s lawyers were arguing their case from the wrong legal section, told the court that an attack on the NPA can not be a reason why “Mr. Downer is lacking in title to prosecute”.
Trengove argued that a complaint of prosecutorial misconduct should not have been allowed before the trial was heard.
Advocate Trengove rebutted all the allegations of misconduct leveled at Downer.
He denied Downer leaked confidential information to the media.
Advocate Trengove asked for the matter to be adjourned to Wednesday when he will wrap up his arguments.
Judge Koen and Zuma’s lawyers agreed.


