Makhanda – Convicted thief Sibongile Mani, who went on a spending spree buying handbags, jackets, alcoholic drinks, and cigarettes with money erroneously paid into her student account from the National Student Financial Aid Scheme (NSFAS), is not going to prison.
As a student at Walter Sisulu University (WSU) Mani erroneously received R14 million from NSFAS and spent over R800 000 on fashion, alcohol, and other vanity items.
On Monday, the High Court of South Africa, Eastern Cape Division, sitting in Makhanda, heard Mani’s appeal against her conviction for theft and sentence.
The High Court dismissed Mani’s appeal against her conviction for theft.
However, it set aside the sentence imposed by the East London Regional Court on 30 March 2022.
The High Court sentenced Mani to a suspended five-year imprisonment term, on condition that she is not convicted of an offence involving fraud or theft during the period of suspension.
In addition, she has been sentenced to:
- undergo three years of correctional supervision,
- to perform 576 hours of community service without compensation, at a community institution,
- to attend regular counselling and rehabilitative programmes offered by the Department of Correctional Services
The accused will be monitored by a correctional services’ official, as delegated by the Head of Community Corrections in Queenstown (Komani).
National Prosecuting Authority Eastern Cape Spokesperson Luxolo Tyali said both courts found that Mani knew that her actions were unlawful, and therefore had the intent to commit fraud.
Before the R14 million was erroneously deposited into her account, Mani never spent her R1 400 monthly stipend from NSFAS on prohibited items.
However, when the R14 million was erroneously deposited into her account, Mani went on a 76-day spending spree, splurging over R800 000.
She spent the money on prohibited items, which included 11 blankets, nine bath sheets, various shorts for men, a variety of alcoholic drinks, cigarettes, 24 jackets, and handbags.
Mani also spent the money in different towns which was proof that she had planned the theft.
The court found that Mani – a student activist, who knew and understood the processes of student financial aid – demonstrated that she deliberately committed the theft and knew that what she was doing was wrong.
Mani did not take the court into her confidence as she declined to testify during the trial, therefore, she chose to exercise her right of remaining silent.
As a result, the court predominantly relied on the evidence of the state to make a judgment.
The Regional court found the state’s evidence and version of events to be truthful and reliable, and the appeal court found the same.


