Judge Ratha Mokgoatlheng’s utterances during the Senzo Meyiwa murder trial last week are unfortunate and sickening.
The judge was playing to the public gallery and TV cameras.
This was after advocate Thulani Mngomezulu had failed to come to court. He reportedly asked a colleague to stand for him.
Mokgoatlheng reportedly reacted: “Are ethics still taught at universities or when doing pupillage or articles? He doesn’t phone the court. This is Africa. The judge is irrelevant.”
It is not the first time nor the last time for a legal representative to miss out on a court date for good or whimsical reasons.
Being a Black judge is not a licence to be condescending, flippantly demeaning, obnoxious, and repugnant.
Not so long ago the same judge in the course of one State witness testimony commented that “he knows that Vosloorus people like news”.
Does the judge come from Vosloorus or as he unsolicitedly revealed on Wednesday?
If you cogitate on what the judge said about Vosloorus people, you will arrive at the only inference that he was sweepingly referring to Blacks residing in townships.
The judge has a tool at his disposal to deal with the absence of counsel.
He has the option of reporting him to the Bar instead of making it all about himself.
Even today he can still demand an explanation from counsel in chambers or in an open court if he is petty and wants to berate and humiliate the advocate.
Last, but not least, in asking those who were in court if ethics are still taught at universities, the judge revealed his shallowness.
The legal profession, the Bar and Side Bar, trains aspirant pupil advocates and candidate attorneys extensively on legal ethics.
To refer to Black lawyers specifically inadvertently the judge revealed his own residual inferiority complex when it comes to his White counterparts in the legal profession.
His belated qualification that he meant some Black lawyers were unethical sounded hollow.
The horse had already bolted and everyone watching the judicial tantrums thrown by this presiding judge now knows his warped views about Black attorneys.
No wonder a few weeks ago the very same judge was namedropping about how he was trained by Arthur Chaskalson and Ishmael Mohammed.
Curiously he never referred to Black mentors.
*The writer of this article is Nhlanhla Mbatha, an independent news commentator, based in Johannesburg. The views expressed by Nhlanhla Mbatha are not necessarily those of The Bulrushes


