Let us call it what it is. A coalition is not democracy. It is a backroom deal dressed up as democracy.
It is what happens when the will of the people fails to produce a winner, and politicians decide to manufacture one for themselves.
Democracy means government of the people, for the people, by the people.
It means the people speak through the ballot, and the voice that speaks loudest governs.
If Party A gets 45%, Party B gets 30%, and Party C gets 25%, the people have spoken clearly. Party A is the first choice of the people.
Party A is the one most South Africans trust to lead them. But in a coalition, that result is thrown away.
Party B and Party C, who were both rejected by the majority, go into a small room, shake hands, add their numbers together, and suddenly they are 55%.
Suddenly the losers are the government.
Just like that,
the party that won the most votes is sitting in opposition, watching two rejected parties govern over the people who did not vote for them.
How is that not political fraud?
The voter did not vote for B and C. No voter went to the ballot box and ticked a box that said: “B and C together.”
That combination was invented after the election, without the voter’s permission. ‘
The mandate was manufactured, not earned. That is why coalitions are cosmetic.
On television, it looks democratic.
There are press conferences, smiles, coalition agreements, fancy words like “stability” and “working together.”
But underneath the make-up, there is no democratic mandate. There is only arithmetic.
Two minorities have combined to cancel a majority. That is not the will of the people.
That is the will of politicians. True democracy requires accountability.
When one party governs, you know who to blame and who to praise. If the roads are broken, if the hospitals collapse, if the water stops, you know who failed.
But in a coalition, accountability disappears. Party B blames Party C. Party C blames Party B.
Both blame the previous government. The voter is left confused, angry, and powerless.
You cannot vote out a coalition because you never voted it in. You cannot punish a deal that was made behind closed doors.
Coalitions also betray the voter’s choice on policy. Imagine you vote for Party B because you believe in its land policy, its economic policy, its stance on jobs.
Then Party B enters a coalition with Party C, whose policies are the opposite.
To stay in power, Party B abandons everything you voted for. It compromises on its manifesto; it waters down its promises; it sells its soul for a mayoral chain or a ministerial post.
What did your vote mean then?
Nothing. Your vote was used as a bargaining chip to get a seat at the table, not to implement the policies you supported.
Look at our metros.
Johannesburg, Tshwane, Ekurhuleni. Since coalitions started, we have seen mayor after mayor, motion after motion, government collapsing every few months.
Not because the people changed their minds, but because small parties with 2% or 3% hold the big parties hostage.
A party that could not even win a ward can decide who becomes mayor of the biggest city in the country. A party the people rejected can become kingmaker.
Is that democracy? No.
That is blackmail with a democratic mask.
A coalition government is a government that no one voted for, led by people the electorate did not choose, implementing policies the people did not approve, and surviving not on public support but on secret deals.
It is a government of the politicians, for the politicians, by the politicians.
If we believe in democracy, we must be honest.
The winner must govern.
If no one wins outright, then let us go back to the people, or let the largest party govern as a minority and be judged on its performance.
But let us stop pretending that adding two losers together makes a winner.
Two wrongs do not make a right.
Two minorities do not make a majority mandate.
Democracy is not mathematics. It is trust. And a coalition breaks that trust on the first day it is formed.
*Nhlanhla Mbatha is an independent current affairs analyst. The views expressed by Nhlanhla Mbatha are not necessarily those of The Bulrushes


