Pretoria – President Cyril Ramaphosa will no longer take Parliament’s Section 89 Phala Phala report on review.
The report found that President Ramaphosa may have committed serious misconduct inconsistent with his office regarding business affairs on his Phala Phala farm.
The Presidency on Monday said: “President Cyril Ramaphosa noted the decision of the Constitutional Court dated 1 March 2023 in which the Court decided not to engage with the merits of the application that he instituted to set aside the report of the independent panel established by the National Assembly in terms of Section 89 of the Constitution (the Panel Report).”
Explaining the development, President Ramaphosa’s spokesperson Vincent Magwenya said: “In the first part of the Presidents review application, he sought leave to bring the case directly to the Constitutional Court, because it was according to the advice he received a matter that fell within its exclusive jurisdiction, and in the interests of justice”.
Magwenya added: “In the second part, he asked that the report of the panel be reviewed, declared unlawful and set aside.
“The Constitutional Court’s decision was on the grounds that the application is not within the Courts exclusive jurisdiction and no compelling case for direct access was made.”
Magwenya said the President respects the ruling of the Constitutional Court.
“The President has been advised which advice he has accepted that the panel report and all issues associated with it have become moot and they are of no practical and legal consequence because on 13 December 2022, the National Assembly decided to reject the motion to refer the Panel Report to an Impeachment Committee,” said Magwenya.
“While that decision remains valid, the Section 89 Panel Report carries no weight in law.
“The President has thus been advised not to institute proceedings before the High Court for the review and setting aside of the Panel Report, at this stage.”
President Ramaphosa reserves his right to bring such proceedings in due course should circumstances change.
Magwenya said President Ramaphosa maintains his position set out in his founding affidavit before the Constitutional Court that the Panel Report is reviewable in law on several grounds including the misconception of its mandate, the grave errors of law, and the unfounded conclusions of fact.
Magwenya made the comments about the Section 89 Report as part of a broader media briefing on various matters.


